How to develop your skills/revise for ‘fact and opinion’ questions

You will be assessed on your ability to distinguish between fact and opinion. You’ll also be expected to comment on how facts and opinions have been used. For example, facts might be use to persuade; to convince; to make a writer’s argument seem more believable; to make an article seem more reliable/trustworthy; to add weight to opinions given and to support points.

To help improve your skills of identifying fact and opinion, get hold of a non-fiction text (e.g. from the BBC news website). Highlight the facts and opinions used and discuss with somebody else why you think these have been used. You might want to write the facts up and give them to another student (out of context) and see if they agree that they are facts – ask them to explain why.

How to develop your skills/revise for ‘following an argument’ questions

Below are a couple of ideas for developing your skills/revising for ‘following an argument’ questions (Paper 1 Section A). It’s a tricky skill to master but at least you’ll know that when you’ve mastered it you will be able to show off – you will be tested on it. You will become better at this if you practice.

1. Cut out a newspaper article, magazine article or print off an article from the web. Work with a partner and label yourselves A and B. A should read the article, out loud, to student B. Student B should tell student A , in their own words, what key/main points are made in the article. Whilst Student B is doing this, student A should jot down the main points. Together you can look over the key points you’ve found and see if you can add any more. You could then have a go at writing this up and peer-assessing each other’s answers but revision doesn’t always have to be about writing – practicing, through talk, identifying key points is a good way to develop your skills of ‘following an argument’.

2. As Rory suggested today, you could go to the BBC news website (http://news.bbc.co.uk/), print off an article and answer the following question: Explain the key points made in the item (6 marks). As it’s worth 6 marks, spend 12 minutes on your answer. You could then use the general mark scheme below to either assess your own work or you could get a friend to peer-assess it. Alternatively, hand it in to me to have a look at.

General Mark Scheme

0 mark   nothing relevant written

1 mark   ‘some simple comment’

  • some simple supported comment
  • mainly narrative description
  • refers to some appropriate detail
  • some references to key points

2 marks   ‘some awareness’

  • some extended supported comments
  • unstructured response and tends to paraphrase
  • some identification of main features
  • some awareness of key points

3-4 marks   ‘clear attempt to select’

  • clear attempt to engage with the task
  • structure response
  • selects and comments
  • a range of key points, 3 at least   * to get a C, you should aim to select 3 or more key points *

5-6   ‘detailed/shaped & absorbed’

  • a full understanding of what is being asked
  • material fully absorbed and shaped for purpose
  • references integrated into argument
  • a detailed and conceptualised response

Full Mark Answer for ‘Following an Argument’

Below is Joe’s fantastic answer from today’s lesson. Use the mark scheme in your book to pick out why Joe got full marks for this – it’s a good example of ‘fully absorbing’ and ‘shaping for purpose’.

Paper 1 Section A from the 2007 series

1. Read item 1 the web page from BBC News online.

a) Explain the key points made in this item.

The article from the BBC explicitly states that smoking in your teens increases the chances of smoking in your later life and consequently death. So it is little wonder that the reporter believes the revolution of mobile phones could be the deterrant to smoking.

The fact that fewer teenagers are smoking and that the ownership of mobile phones is rising confirms the point made in this article stating that mobiles are replacing cigarettes as a form of rebellion.

The reporter feels that owning a mobile may serve as a stopper in another way – they believe that it’s unlikely for the teenagers to be able to fund both this addiction to cigarettes and modern technology.

However, the reporter does understand that not all teenage smokers will stop smoking merely due to new symbol of defiance and so makes a point of warning the public about the dangers of smoking and cancer.

How are the AOs targeted in Paper 1 Section A?

From now on, each question in Paper 1 Section A will assess a particular assessment objective. This is how the assessment objectives will be targeted:

The following AOs will be assessed in all questions in Section A rather than in specific questions:

  • read, with insight and engagement, making appropriate references to texts (i)
  • select material appropriate to their purpose ( iv)

Question 1 (a) tests the ability to follow an argument (iii)

Question 1 (b) tests the ability to distinguish between fact and opinion (ii)

Question 2 (a) and 2 (b) will test the ability to understand and evaluate how writers use linguistic, structural and presenational devices to achieve their effects (v)

Either Question 2(a) or 2(b) will test the ability to make cross references (iv)

Assessment Objectives for Paper 1 Section A

Below are the Assessment Objectives tested in Paper 1 Section A. Beneath each objective is the more ‘student friendly’ version we came up with in today’s lesson.

(i) read, with insight and engagement, making appropriate references to texts and developing and sustaining interpretations of them

(ii) distinguish between fact and opinion and evaluate how information is presented

(iii) follow an argument, identifying implications and recognising inconsistencies

(iv) select material appropriate to their purpose, collate material from different sources, and make cross-references

(v) understand and evaluate how writers use linguistic, structural and presentational devices to achieve their effects, and comment on ways language varies and changes.

Glossary of Terms for Paper 1 Section A Questions

Sometimes it’s not easy to understand what an exam question is asking us to do. Below are some terms you will see in Section A of Paper 1, and the Assessment Objectives we have looked at in class, with an explanation of what they mean and implications for your answers.

‘distinguish between fact and opinion’

Tell the difference between a fact that can be proved to be true and an opinion which cannot. Facts tend to be found close to numbers and factual statments like ‘research has proved that’. Opinions tend to be hedge with words like: ‘perhaps’, ‘usually’, ‘it is thought that’, ‘possibly’, or they may be coupled with adjectives or adverbs such as: ‘incredible, ‘terribly’ etc.

At Higher Tier level, you will be asked to explain how facts and opinions are used.

‘explain in your own words’

You should not simply copy passages out of the original items. Obviously, you will have to re-cycle some of the words in the original, but you have to show that you have ‘followed an argument’ and ‘read, with insight and engagement’. To achieve in the top mark ranges in this type of question, you have to show that you have absorbed and shaped the material to make it fit for purpose. ‘Explain…’ expects you to give reasons, clarify, or give an account.

Less successful answers will involve just copying or paraphrasing the material with little attention to the question.

‘follow an argument’

What do you understand from this item, or, what is the writer trying to say on this particular subject. Candidates should be able to recognise the main points a writer is making and to show how they have started – developed – ended their argument. Higher order readers will show that they have followed an argument by answering the specific question and by using their own words as far as possible, apart from where they…

‘select information appropriate to’

Using direct questions, references, or allusions to the item(s) in order to help to show that you have followed the argument, or answered a question in relation to other Assessment Objectives. Copying out chunks of material is not necessarily ‘appropriate’, whilst embedding short quotations within a sentence might fulfil the purpose more succinctly.

‘compare’

What is the same and what is different between the two items? You will need to use comparative connectives e.g. ‘similarly’, ‘whereas’, ‘on the other hand’ etc. to make the comparisons clear.

‘print’

The writing on the page, including font sizes, styles and colours etc.

‘uses of language’

In what ways does the writer use language to fulfil the purpose of the piece of writing? The answer will usually include some, or all, of the following: sentence length; use of verbs/nouns/adjectives/adverbs; use of rhetorical devices; the person used and resulting pronoun choices; vocabulary choice; repetition, etc. You should be thinking of the kind of language choices writers make to suit the audience and fulfil the purpose of the item. You should always comment on the effect of the language choice.

‘presentation’ and ‘layout’

These terms refer to the choices made when arranging material on a page in order to fulfil its purpose and to appeal to an audience. The AO s include the term ‘structural and presentation devices’ meaning you have to refer to the positioning as well as devices used to help meaning. These include use of colour, headlines, sub-headings, bullet points, italics, font styles, pictures and diagrams etc.

‘form’

This term will invariably be used within the specific media questions. Each medium has different forms of the same product, e.g. a newspaper can come in the form of a broadsheet, or a tabloid. Historically, these forms bring certain expectations with them, but there can be variations within the forms (e.g. between the Daily Mail and The Sun).

‘read them as media texts’

This means that you will now have to read the items with a view to answering the questions aaimed at fulfilling the specific media content of this component. This means that you will read the texts with a view to the producer’s prupose, audience, medium and context.

‘effective’ or ‘effectiveness’

Write about how well the item(s) has worked and comment on whether it has fulfilled its purpose in terms of language, layout, form, argument, structure, presentational devices.

‘image’

The photographic image, or picture, takes up a large part of print-based media. Creating an image involves the selection of real objects, or people, and presenting them in a way that has some meaning to the viewer. You should write about an image in terms of technical aspects (such as the camera angle); where the image is placed in relation to the accompanying text and how it links to the text.

‘meaning is conveyed’

You need to be able to recognise the way(s) in which the producer of an item gets across what is being said, or the message. ‘Conveyed’ means ‘put across to the reader’ and can include many different aspects of the text including presentation, layout, print, image, etc.

Text for PALL Analysis – Phones 4 U Girls

find-phones-4u-girls-on-facebook

Follow this link if you have problems looking at it on this blog:

http://the3gdatingagency.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/find-phones-4u-girls-on-facebook.jpeg

Text for PALL analysis – Drugs and Substance Misuse

anti-stigma-campaign-drugs

P A L L Analysis of Non-Fiction and Media Texts

For Paper 1 Section A you will need to quickly identify and be able to comment on the Purpose, Audience, Language and Layout of the text(s) given.

To help prepare for this part of the exam, I suggest you regularly do a PALL analysis of texts you can get your hands on. The more often you do it, the more comfortable and confident you will be with identifying features and commenting on writers’ intentions.

To do a PALL analysis of any texts, just stick a  media or non-fiction text into the middle of the page and start annotating using the prompts below. I will posts media and non-fiction texts on here so that you can conduct a PALL analysis. I’m more than happy to look at work that you do independently in preparation for the exam.

PALL Analysis (Purpose Audience Language Layout)

Form

(TIP: On the front of the insert you will be told what the texts are and where they come from)

 What type of text is it?

Leaflet/Poster/ Magazine advert/Newspaper article/

 Purpose

 What does the writing aim to do?

Argue/Persuade/Advise/Inform/Explain/Describe/Analyse/Review/

Comment/Instruct?

 Audience

 Who is the text written for?

Teenagers/Women/Men/Pensioners/Parents/People with particular interests

 Language

(TIP: Always explain the effect of choices made. What is the writer’s intention?)

 Consider the formality of the piece.

Formal/Informal

 What’s the mode of address?

1st person (I)/2nd person (you)/3rd person (he/she/they)/personal/ impersonal/detached

 What types of words or phrases are being used?

Technical/scientific/descriptive/informative/factual/emotive/serious/ humorous

 What linguistic devices are being used?

Fact/Opinion/Rhetorical questions/hyperbole (exaggeration)/irony/ anecdote/puns

Layout

(TIP: Always explain the effect of choices made. What is the writer’s intention?)

 How is the text presented?

Headlines/Sub-headings/Slogans/Itallics/Bullet points/Bold text/Photos/

Diagrams/Logos/Colour/Captions/Columns/Boxes/Cartoons/Grids